I also want to bring up the survey I ran for a bit. I wrote up the results here: http://satelle.is-very-evil.org/moodle/ ... ?entryid=2
I think in cases like the FA and other sites, you have Content, and you have Presenting Content. You can have very good content, but if it's hard to access or the site is broken, it doesn't matter much. If you have a good presentation but the content is not good, same thing. Regardless of your opinion of surveys, it's a pretty good representation of the sorts of people who use websites like this, and what they look for in broad enough terms to apply to many types of content. It's intended to help improve both Content and Presenting Content, so hopefully it did that.